WASHINGTON(AP)
Months of tumultuous negotiations with the White House and GOP
allies have brought the Senate's liberal lion, Edward M.
Kennedy, to the brink of passing a bill to legalize up to 12
million unlawful immigrants.
But his concessions to get there have alienated liberals who in
the past have counted him as their strongest champion. A showdown
test vote is scheduled Tuesday, and the Senate could pass _ or
reject _ the bill by week's end.
Traditional Kennedy allies are mystified and angry at the
Massachusetts senator's willingness to accept Republican-backed
measures such as subjecting illegal immigrants to steep fines and
trips home, separating immigrants from relatives and letting new
guest workers stay only for short periods of time with little
chance of citizenship.
"I think that in his heart, he's where I'm at, but
he wants to see a deal move forward and he's willing to take
certain steps that I might not be willing to take," said Sen.
Robert Menendez, D-N.J., who abandoned the deal just before it was
announced because it scrapped many immigrants' ability to come
to the U.S. based solely on family ties.
"In the pursuit of moving us along, he's probably
swallowed hard on some things that he himself would not have
accepted" otherwise, Menendez added.
It's a familiar spot for Kennedy, 75, whose standing as a
liberal firebrand during his 45 years in the Senate belies his
history of partnering with Republicans on major domestic agenda
items.
He's done so twice before with President Bush, on the No
Child Left Behind education law and a broad Medicare prescription
drug overhaul. In both cases, Kennedy was accused by liberals of
compromising too much in the interests of a deal.
"You can hold to rigid positions in the United States
Senate _ and I respect that _ and get nothing done, or you can try
and find common ground," Kennedy said in an interview with The
Associated Press.
He regards an immigration overhaul as the civil rights
imperative of the 21st century, and sees the same legacies of
prejudice and discrimination standing in the way. Legalizing 12
million unlawful immigrants "is worth the fight," Kennedy
said.
Kennedy's pragmatic history and his expertise _ he
maneuvered a broad immigration overhaul through the Senate in 1965,
during his second term _ has earned him Bush's trust.
"Senator Kennedy is one of the best legislative senators
there is. He can get the job done. I know firsthand, because we
reformed our education system," Bush said at a March news
conference in Mexico.
Some activists who revere Kennedy privately voice a sense of
betrayal at the lengths to which he has been willing to go in
search of a deal.
The AFL-CIO condemned the bill last week, and its leaders have
harsh words for the senator they trusted to shepherd a historic
immigration measure.
"I am angry," said Ed Sullivan, president of the labor
federation's building and construction trades department, and a
Massachusetts native who describes Kennedy as a "good
friend." "We can't understand how our senators would
support this."
Sullivan said Kennedy's intentions were good, but his
pragmatism drew him into a bad deal.
"I think he's locked in. He's a legislator that
likes to pass legislation," Sullivan said.
In early March, representatives of liberal groups angrily
cautioned Kennedy against starting negotiations with Bush's
team and a group of senators led by conservative Jon Kyl, R-Ariz.,
on an immigration compromise that could attract GOP support.
Kennedy contended it was the only way to craft a bill that would
survive.
Months later, just before Kennedy went before news cameras to
announce his breakthrough immigration deal with Republicans and the
White House, some of them complained he had agreed to a shabby
bargain that would rip families apart and sentence millions more
immigrants to exploitation from abusive employers.
"We were saying, 'Senator, we think you're going
too far,'" said Frank Sharry, executive director of the
National Immigration Forum. "He told us, 'You're not
going far enough. If you want to get this done, you've got to
get real. I've been around this place 40 years. This is the
best we can do. If you want to get it done, follow
me.'"
He may have sounded unshakable, but Kennedy admits to some
moments of doubt during the roller coaster process of crafting the
bill.
"Of course there are times when we really wonder whether it
continues to make sense to engage in this," Kennedy said.
"It's a battle."
Ultimately, though, he said, "I believe in the legislation.
The alternative to this is nothing, and that's, I think,
completely unacceptable."
Kennedy's involvement has made the immigration deal more
difficult for some Republicans to stomach. Conservative critics of
the plan brand it the "Kennedy-Bush amnesty" program, and
invoke the Massachusetts senator's name to paint it as a
far-left solution.
Sen. Trent Lott, R-Miss., has weathered bitter criticism back
home for supporting the measure. NumbersUSA, an anti-immigration
group, ran ads last week that juxtaposed Lott's picture next to
Kennedy's and said Lott had "joined with Ted Kennedy in
strong-arming senators to support amnesty for millions of illegals,
many of whom have already taken jobs from Mississippi
workers."
Kyl called working with Kennedy "a real
education."
"He's a tough bargainer. He's a real strong
advocate for some points of view with which I disagree, but I have
found him to be a man of his word, and on the emotional and
difficult issue of immigration reform, that's a big deal,"
Kyl said.
___
The bill is S 1639.
Copyright 2007 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.